A few months ago, I took a board game prototype with me to Protospiel Minneapolis. I called it Mine Rush, and it was something that I had sitting on the back burner for a few years. I put it together in 12 hours, and quickly realized the early iterations were *rough*. It needed a lot of work. Over the span of that one weekend, I played a good dozen games of Mine Rush with different people and got a bunch of good feedback. <center></center> The early iterations involved reaching treasure nodes (marked with a yellow "T") where you could try to roll a die to acquire a gemstone that you could bring back to the entrance for some gold. The first couple playtests were ploddingly slow, this game was seriously lacking in the fun department. As I iterated, I figured out a press your luck mechanic for acquiring gemstones definitely helped speed things along. It was good! <center></center> After that weekend, I found what I thought was a sweet spot. Gameplay was snappy, the risk-reward of the mining worked, and it was overall decent. A couple publishers took notice of the game and liked it too. But there were a few lingering problems. For one, a bunch of people disliked the "roll to move" mechanic. It's not for everyone, but when I tried limiting the number of moves, it didn't feel like it worked the way I wanted it to. It still felt too slow. Second, while looking into the costs of producing this game, I realized that the number of cards and parts is too much to fit into the packaging that I'm targeting for this game. I needed to get the game components into a more compact grouping to keep production costs down. To do this, I made a pretty big rework. First, I removed the gemstone cards and the order cards. The only deck of cards is now just the Event cards. I instead added some gold tokens that can be used to keep track of things. Second, I removed the roll to move and instead added a limited number of actions. These can be spent moving around or digging for the gold. The results were massive:  The game moves a lot faster now! I played two rounds with my wife and son last night. We were done in about half an hour. That's not necessarily a bad thing, either! I might add more ways to slow people down, we'll have to see on that. But the game is progressing nicely. Here's hoping next month's Protospiel leads to a publisher picking up the game. It's a long shot, I know. But one can always hope!
author | ddrfr33k |
---|---|
permlink | i-love-it-when-rules-changes-work-out-great |
category | hive-140217 |
json_metadata | {"app":"peakd/2025.4.6","format":"markdown","tags":["gamedev","tabletop","gaming","blog","palnet","neoxian"],"users":[],"image":["https://files.peakd.com/file/peakd-hive/ddrfr33k/23uFPkei8qixcG168jAzoFpT5H4qZ3r3ry82BstNpG4GZz1URUKkQB6pBFhyQGYK65mjJ.png","https://files.peakd.com/file/peakd-hive/ddrfr33k/EoErW2RTewbschNixgGwjw8TrNQxUpznZ4nGqudEuvzoFatnk6XWFQWZp4ZfhwNXUuK.png","https://files.peakd.com/file/peakd-hive/ddrfr33k/23u67YJQGScrfU6zfpbxbVpmaQPiZqN4mkYA7P5hbD2YoYzJ6sLLxrVkPTYS9jRCbzR1T.jpg"]} |
created | 2025-04-28 14:08:45 |
last_update | 2025-04-28 14:08:45 |
depth | 0 |
children | 0 |
last_payout | 2025-05-05 14:08:45 |
cashout_time | 1969-12-31 23:59:59 |
total_payout_value | 1.532 HBD |
curator_payout_value | 1.514 HBD |
pending_payout_value | 0.000 HBD |
promoted | 0.000 HBD |
body_length | 2,838 |
author_reputation | 131,238,077,107,751 |
root_title | "I love it when rules changes work out great!" |
beneficiaries | [] |
max_accepted_payout | 1,000,000.000 HBD |
percent_hbd | 10,000 |
post_id | 142,373,326 |
net_rshares | 8,829,668,787,662 |
author_curate_reward | "" |
voter | weight | wgt% | rshares | pct | time |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
jeffjagoe | 0 | 2,937,772,466 | 3.75% | ||
chiren | 0 | 58,020,241,509 | 100% | ||
ripperone | 0 | 3,459,153,981,020 | 38% | ||
schlees | 0 | 605,573,463,008 | 37.5% | ||
web-gnar | 0 | 424,509,971,810 | 100% | ||
mblain | 0 | 454,272,719 | 37.5% | ||
derosnec | 0 | 847,490,515 | 4% | ||
paulag | 0 | 4,621,231,682 | 10% | ||
sirjaxxy | 0 | 554,458,077 | 50% | ||
joeyarnoldvn | 0 | 453,006,511 | 1.47% | ||
gamesjoyce | 0 | 5,287,025,363 | 18.75% | ||
warjar | 0 | 461,137,419 | 100% | ||
sharelovenothate | 0 | 893,348,793 | 37.5% | ||
my-art-way | 0 | 90,000,641,247 | 60% | ||
niallon11 | 0 | 3,161,502,428 | 0.4% | ||
calimeatwagon | 0 | 2,369,824,222 | 37.5% | ||
jlsplatts | 0 | 25,988,875,346 | 2% | ||
socent | 0 | 1,588,921,932 | 15% | ||
bluefinstudios | 0 | 1,115,611,970 | 0.4% | ||
helpie | 0 | 9,837,041,402 | 8% | ||
rcshad0w | 0 | 44,910,275,210 | 62% | ||
markaustin | 0 | 796,208,157 | 5% | ||
spiritabsolute | 0 | 41,306,075,307 | 100% | ||
jrungi | 0 | 707,020,135 | 18.75% | ||
lethsrock | 0 | 616,068,298 | 50% | ||
soulturtle | 0 | 474,463,616 | 1.6% | ||
nerdtopiade | 0 | 25,934,987,429 | 51.75% | ||
slacktmusic | 0 | 858,018,178 | 4% | ||
smjn | 0 | 755,027,009,931 | 100% | ||
bennettitalia | 0 | 3,083,434,784 | 4% | ||
dynamicrypto | 0 | 38,577,326,502 | 75% | ||
jakeeyexe | 0 | 955,617,018 | 50% | ||
minedovermatter | 0 | 981,488,394 | 100% | ||
mproxima | 0 | 43,300,847,280 | 30% | ||
macslin | 0 | 6,546,872,909 | 100% | ||
thisbejake | 0 | 1,108,081,272 | 18.75% | ||
ajaxalot | 0 | 1,502,397,637 | 1.87% | ||
zipporah | 0 | 4,165,429,459 | 1.6% | ||
doomsdaychassis | 0 | 1,559,665,736 | 8% | ||
satren | 0 | 37,128,381,422 | 20% | ||
jeronimorubio | 0 | 768,866,097 | 8% | ||
shobek | 0 | 867,544,487 | 18.75% | ||
nebuladream | 0 | 653,727,337 | 18.75% | ||
dotwin1981 | 0 | 195,735,595,890 | 30% | ||
reversehitler88 | 0 | 2,690,606,541 | 18.75% | ||
kanrat | 0 | 27,259,262,649 | 37.5% | ||
racibo | 0 | 6,697,312,620 | 5% | ||
naruitchi | 0 | 2,341,709,301 | 18.75% | ||
camuel | 0 | 4,185,181,049 | 25% | ||
raorac | 0 | 1,303,239,217 | 35% | ||
retard-gamer-de | 0 | 472,015,979 | 18.75% | ||
yaraha | 0 | 6,161,710,252 | 37.5% | ||
solominer | 0 | 1,156,755,634,147 | 5% | ||
youraverageguy | 0 | 647,942,458 | 50% | ||
dunite | 0 | 4,054,482,321 | 37.5% | ||
sbi4 | 0 | 71,948,723,794 | 6.02% | ||
celinavisaez | 0 | 6,439,909,452 | 17% | ||
aceaeterna | 0 | 1,891,655,510 | 18.75% | ||
justasperm | 0 | 740,402,481 | 18.75% | ||
crimo | 0 | 1,019,244,224 | 18.75% | ||
viniciotricolor | 0 | 4,613,723,874 | 37.5% | ||
free-reign | 0 | 1,418,020,999 | 1.2% | ||
chansetheguy | 0 | 1,078,221,245 | 5.62% | ||
dgi | 0 | 4,733,493,437 | 100% | ||
thedailysneak | 0 | 575,850,416 | 0.68% | ||
bflanagin | 0 | 3,768,165,028 | 4% | ||
schlunior | 0 | 40,030,032,352 | 37.5% | ||
melor9 | 0 | 844,649,801 | 4% | ||
lillywilton | 0 | 4,883,809,443 | 20% | ||
zappos | 0 | 930,265,896 | 100% | ||
pewsplosions | 0 | 134,613,330,948 | 100% | ||
voxmortis | 0 | 14,123,406,977 | 7.5% | ||
altonos | 0 | 949,379,687 | 18.75% | ||
vimm | 0 | 178,693,304,853 | 37.5% | ||
eonwarp | 0 | 5,391,130,262 | 100% | ||
chisdealhd | 0 | 19,039,923,187 | 30% | ||
kaldewei | 0 | 894,168,821 | 37.5% | ||
bilderkiste | 0 | 773,147,080 | 75% | ||
princessamber | 0 | 1,151,496,542 | 50% | ||
helpie-caster | 0 | 65,809,024,934 | 75% | ||
ghostdylan | 0 | 1,156,104,892 | 50% | ||
mr-wallstreet | 0 | 2,194,558,409 | 100% | ||
magdalena1b | 0 | 858,440,795 | 37.5% | ||
kggymlife | 0 | 3,832,648,322 | 20% | ||
wallvater | 0 | 2,088,083,685 | 37.5% | ||
tinyhousecryptos | 0 | 469,956,843 | 5% | ||
sbi-tokens | 0 | 1,086,394,750 | 1.36% | ||
whangster79 | 0 | 1,278,344,472 | 5% | ||
unpopular | 0 | 175,878,562,397 | 19% | ||
mvanhauten | 0 | 893,272,178 | 37.5% | ||
kamilla19 | 0 | 94,822,756,588 | 20% | ||
kreur | 0 | 135,078,778,554 | 50% | ||
azar0307 | 0 | 715,569,662 | 37.5% | ||
ciderjunkie | 0 | 93,724,873,433 | 56.25% | ||
recoveryinc | 0 | 1,604,731,010 | 2.5% | ||
dragokazo | 0 | 16,354,612,217 | 100% | ||
pbcrypto | 0 | 1,394,581,592 | 100% | ||
gabrieljr | 0 | 531,377,699 | 18.75% | ||
druckado | 0 | 1,191,052,708 | 37.5% | ||
samrisso | 0 | 1,730,404,088 | 2.5% | ||
bobthebuilder2 | 0 | 39,132,053,392 | 50% | ||
tomtothetom | 0 | 731,861,730 | 5% | ||
t-nil | 0 | 1,145,521,254 | 20% | ||
dungeondog | 0 | 28,348,316,517 | 37.5% | ||
ischmieregal | 0 | 13,589,060,656 | 37.5% | ||
r0nny | 0 | 13,775,867,648 | 37.5% | ||
rosmiapure | 0 | 2,683,518,470 | 50% | ||
dagamers7 | 0 | 1,010,667,409 | 37.5% | ||
alloyxuast | 0 | 32,152,688,122 | 50% | ||
acantoni | 0 | 742,755,370 | 2.5% | ||
waffleuncle | 0 | 1,423,172,330 | 30% | ||
psyberx | 0 | 200,297,875,832 | 100% | ||
swearingradio | 0 | 1,145,358,124 | 28.12% | ||
low-key103 | 0 | 387,112,236 | 50% | ||
imoogin3v3rm0r3 | 0 | 2,495,239,396 | 30% | ||
aceyaan | 0 | 468,738,388 | 37.5% | ||
der.merlin | 0 | 1,513,504,308 | 37.5% | ||
sydechan | 0 | 198,292,642,747 | 18% | ||
psyber-x | 0 | 4,223,494,828 | 100% | ||
stream4fun | 0 | 725,929,633 | 30% | ||
devmarvel | 0 | 1,457,184,674 | 37.5% | ||
actordontee | 0 | 4,099,526,760 | 18.75% | ||
lu1sa | 0 | 589,186,350 | 37.5% | ||
pit3r | 0 | 6,606,390,096 | 37.5% | ||
y3ssi | 0 | 6,383,849,121 | 37.5% | ||
hive-bounty | 0 | 896,725,677 | 37.5% | ||
stoken.quest | 0 | 8,321,438,852 | 100% | ||
thezyppi | 0 | 10,886,638,256 | 37.5% | ||
unsubscribe | 0 | 501,499,901 | 90% | ||
masterrpgbot | 0 | 430,452,688 | 100% | ||
rainfirevt | 0 | 777,348,229 | 30% | ||
imoog1en3v3rm0r3 | 0 | 1,644,197,357 | 30% | ||
chyxille | 0 | 13,373,519,300 | 100% | ||
stingyfly | 0 | 748,971,744 | 57.75% | ||
demonicore | 0 | 1,442,561,668 | 25% | ||
alexandrefeliz | 0 | 3,185,750,639 | 50% | ||
nekolive | 0 | 768,512,606 | 30% | ||
lala1227 | 0 | 1,408,670,362 | 100% | ||
magic.byte | 0 | 0 | 100% | ||
shadow302 | 0 | 657,080,997 | 30% |