good work boss, keep it up.

can you give us information about the bids of all bots and reward that users are gaining through these bid bots if any?

Thanks for sharing

Thanks @penguinpablo
 The results of your work is very helpful to us steemit players.
I will wait for the next your update.

very good work buddy. carry on your self. i will check your link.

it would be nice to see that figure plus self upvotes, just to see what it looks like

Great analysis,Your data shows big number of Upvotes done by voting bots.
So what should be the strategy of newbies to flourish on Steemit.
I'm seeking sincere opinion from Seniors and experts.
thanking you in anticipation.
:)

It would be interesting to know how much Steem power does bots have as opposed to human user accounts. Delegated SP can be counted as their own SP. 
Just in case we have a bot vs human war here on Steemit. Who will win.

What portion of steem rewards (re)distibuted through voting bots?

Could you calc it?

Que bueno su punto de vista unos exelentes votos  felicidades hermano exito para usted

*Thanks for sharing this informative data with us and it's really amazing to see that one bot is upvoting more than 10000 posts every day and it's an great thing. Thanks for sharing and wishing you an great day Keep up the great day. Stay blessed. 🙂*

Interesting. I am curious how many of those upvotes are self upvotes? I wrote article about necessary changes in Steemit in my opinion:
https://steemit.com/steem/@cicbar/steemit-necessary-changes

1.7% of upvotes by paid bots, that doesn't really indicate this is a big issue. Perhaps I have to adjust my opinion?

However I think the value of the upvotes is more important than the number of upvotes. As some of these bots could be the biggest whales around. Perhaps you can also have a look at that?

Nice post. It's helpful to see the data. While only ~2% of votes are by paid bots, I'd guess the percent of voting power from paid bots is much higher.

Not sure I love the multiple y-axes in each plot... it's easy to mistake to the votes and paid votes as being on the same scale. I'd recommend plots like these (from my [recent blog post](http://blog.dhimmel.com/citation-styles/)):

![Popularity of citation styles by year](https://gitlab.com/dhimmel/pmc-citation-styles/raw/d08b920861aef667ef7edb84c12c35ba119a69df/figure/years-mutlipanel.png)

On the left you've got raw counts (in your case the two categories would be paid votes & unpaid votes). On the right you've got normalized votes. You'd probably want to zoom in the y-axis, given that such a low number of votes are paid.

An alternative would be a faceted plot, where the paid and total plots were vertically aligned but separate.

Keep up the great #datascience!

it's very good my friend...
I really hope to be like you 😊

Interesting, 11k bot votes a day is so much. Always wondered about this but never knew how to find out, so thanks for sharing this.

Mhh, a lot less than I expected. When I did read the tittle I had a figure in my mind before opening and reading the post. To be honest I was thinking about 30 to 35%.
I think if we would add some groups in the calculations that probably the more richer Steemians are using them. A lot more than the red fishes.
@penguinpablo it is possible to dig this up?
The answer to this question will probably prove that more wintered Steemians are using upvote bots compared to relative newer Steemians.
But I could be wrong!

Interesting, 1.7% is quite alot! I think think the results would be more interesting if you could show of how much of the total rewards was distributed by the upvote bots in contrast to the total amount of upvote value.

These doesn't include votes from SteemAuto as that's not a paid service [as yet] , right?

That was precise, It's interesting how we utilize resources to get upvote on our work. But I can see there is still handful of community which doesn't use this voting bot system.

The REAL question is, do the voting bots help those who use them?

Hello, you have a VERY COOL blog and this post is extremely useful. I will follow you and I will encourage you to do so too.

me on my blog PUBLISHES super modeling sessions and DAILY adds new ones :)

it's such a TIME FOR OPENING on STEEMIT :) best regards Gordon :)![woman-2794670_1280.jpg](https://steemitimages.com/DQmbfDQ5hej4pGAB3o85Wdw7Hg7Q2vQAfX4ZNCPQwYT5snv/woman-2794670_1280.jpg)

ok  but i think the votes with higher values are with the bot and the whales, i think that is why most people prefer to pay for bots

Great insight, that's a lot of bots. what would the worst case scenario? could this de-stabilize the steem platform as more and more paid bots are deployed? minting the Steem tokens more rapidly could be one scenario, but how that plays out is yet to be known. curious to find out tho..

very interesting, I thought it would be much larger amount

grate...it's helpful for us..thank you for share..good job boss.carry on

i get it. number of upvotes from paid bots and not value of upvotes from paid bots. ofcourse number of upvotes bots did cannot be compared with number of upvotes from steemians but what interests me more is value of upvotes from paid bots as againts value of upvotes from steemians.

interesting

Did you take into account the fact that those bots also carry delegated votes that don't show up with the bots name on them?

I like your statistics, they truly illustrate the objective, which I'm not sure if those bot are a benefit? Is it better to pay?

I only discovered steembottracker.com the other day and it is interesting to see more information related to voting bots. 

Could you please assist in providng more information on voting bots: 

* How much Steem Power is owned by the bots?
* How much Steem Power is delegated to the bots?
* How much Steem Power is controlled by the bots?
* How much of the daily posting rewards is allocated by the bots?
* How much of the daily curation rewards is earned by the bots?