Part 1/10:

# Critical Review of Netflix's Live Action *Cowboy Bebop*: A Disappointing Adaptation

Netflix's ambitious live-action adaptation of the beloved anime *Cowboy Bebop* has set the internet abuzz—mostly with disappointment and frustration. Fans and casual viewers alike are voicing concerns, and early reactions suggest that the show falls far short of capturing the spirit and depth of the original series.

## An Ill-Fated Live Action Attempt

Part 2/10:

The initial impressions are overwhelmingly negative. The reviewer, Neon, watched only the first episode and even skipped ahead to the final episode, driven mainly by curiosity about the character Edward. The verdict? *Cringe-worthy*—a harsh but fair adjective to describe the portrayal of Ed, whose live-action incarnation reportedly resembles the cringe-inducing Pippi Longstocking from the '80s and '90s, making fans cringe rather than sympathize.

Neon notes that the show is *not just not good* but *awfully executed*. Although the episode started with some promise—evoking Tarantino's stylized *Speed Racer* film, with bright colors and theatrical lighting—the enthusiasm quickly evaporated as the show devolved into a confusing mess of questionable casting and storytelling choices.

Part 3/10:

## Casting and Character Changes: A Disservice to Fans

The adaptation's casting choices drew immediate ire. J. Michael Cho as Spike and Mustafa Shakir as Jet are seen as *competent but unremarkable*, neither elevating the show, but their performances aren't outright failures. Conversely, the portrayal of Faye Valentine is disastrous. Neon describes her as *obnoxious*, *unlikable*, and *snarky to the point of annoyance*, with a costume and personality that feel far removed from the charismatic and alluring original.

Part 4/10:

Most notably, the character of Ed is portrayed by a young actor who is *non-binary*, a decision that Neon criticizes severely. The live-action Ed is described as *cringy* and *obnoxious*, with the horror being that this character only appears for about a minute at the end of the season. The original Ed, a quintessentially energetic and endearing hacker, is present only in fleeting glimpses, leading to a sentiment of frustration among fans who cherished her arc.

## Drastic Rewrites and Plot Changes

Beyond casting, the series takes many creative liberties that diverge significantly from the anime. Among the most notable revisions:

- **Spike** is renamed "Fearless" and loses his iconic cybernetic eye, replacing it with a more generic appearance.

Part 5/10:

- **Vicious** is given increased screen time, questioning his mysterious nature and providing a more explicit backstory involving his father, who turns out to be the elderly leader of the Syndicate. This shift aims to deepen Vicious’s villainy but may undermine the subtlety that made the anime's Vicious a compelling enigma.

- **Julia**, a pivotal character, survives and actively influences the plot, portraying a far more active and manipulative role than the anime's mysterious figure.

### Faye Valentine and the Crew

Part 6/10:

Faye’s reimagining is a significant departure. She is now depicted as *more demanding, angrier*, with a more modern, Twitter-esque attitude—an abrasive personality that fans find hard to reconcile with her original flirtatious and playful personality. Her wardrobe has also been changed, further emphasizing her "more demanding" demeanor.

Jet’s backstory is altered to include his ex-wife and daughter, adding unnecessary personal drama that feels out of place in the universe’s gritty space bounty-hunting setting. The beloved genetically engineered Corgi, Ein, is present but possibly robotic, with powers that remain unexplained, adding to the show's inconsistent tone.

## The Disappointing Execution and Visuals

Part 7/10:

Neon mentions that certain elements, like space visuals, look decent. However, the overall production feels *budget-constrained* and *fan-filmy*, lacking the polish and atmosphere of the anime. The series appears to have been filmed in front of large screens typical for Disney or studio productions, but the result is underwhelming.

The "fun" aspects of the original—such as the complex relationships, jazzy soundtrack, and nuanced character development—are missing or poorly adapted. Instead, the show feels *forced*, *inconsistent*, and *unsatisfying*.

## Fan Frustration and the Future of the Series

Part 8/10:

The review strongly hints at a second season being planned or already in the works, but Neon is resolute in his disdain: *"Just kill it with fire."* Fans of the original series are likely to be disappointed, especially with the portrayal of Edward, whose live-action form is described as *absolutely cringe-worthy*.

The ending leaves room for a second season, with some foreshadowing, but Neon’s final words suggest that continuing to watch would be a *torture* for hardcore fans and even casual viewers.

## Final Verdict: A Fail on All Counts

Part 9/10:

On a scale of 1 to 10, the show scores roughly a 3. It has some minor positives—like certain visual effects and performances—but these are vastly overshadowed by miscasting, errant characterizations, and an overall sense of budget-cut fanfic. The series’ attempt to overhaul beloved characters and narratives results in a product that feels disconnected from the source material.

For fans of *Cowboy Bebop*, this adaptation is less a tribute and more a travesty. Neon’s message is clear: *"Kill it with fire."* As it stands, the series is unlikely to satisfy even casual viewers expecting a faithful adaptation and is best avoided until Netflix and the creative team make significant changes—or abandon it altogether.

---

Part 10/10:

**In summary:** Netflix’s *Cowboy Bebop* live-action adaptation is a spectacular failure, riddled with shallow characterizations, excessive creative liberties, and a tone inconsistent with the original anime. Fans can only hope for a cancellation or a major overhaul before further damage is done to this treasured franchise.