thanks for your considered response here. one reason that natural immunity is more effective than the shots, including even in the short term before the effects of the shots wears off, is that the shots only target the spike protein and not the entire virus. natural immunity targets the whole virus- all its other parts.
however, the situation is much more complicated. 
the data clearly shows that immediately after every iteration of shots more people die. the deaths occur within 48 hours of rollout in large numbers, which is entirely consistent with vaccine induced deaths and not possible from the disease itself. If you look at my previous, linked, posts you will find this in over 90 countries. in particular, note the island which had zero covid until the vaccines arrived.