| json_metadata | "{"app":"musing/1.1","appTags":["life","story"],"appCategory":"life","appTitle":"Who is on the cross of a Christian, Jesus or someone else who is similar to him?","appBody":"<p>In this case, things that relate to faith and I never force anyone to believe, acknowledge and justify my opinions and arguments. I appreciate every difference. And also Islam never forces peoples of other religions to embrace Islam.</p>\n<p>In the Qur'an explained Jesus did not die on the cross. A man who died on the cross was only people who were likened to him.</p>\n<p>Jewish Sayings: \"We have killed the Messiah, Isa the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah\", even though they did not kill him and did not (also) crucify him, but (those who killed it) were likened to Jesus to them. Lo! Those who disagree about (killing) Jesus, in doubt about the murdered. They do not have confidence about who issued it, except following mere assumptions, they are not (also) sure what they bring is Isa. (Surat an-Nisa: 157)</p>\n<p>Then who be killed, Jesus or not?</p>\n<p>Ibn Abbas radhiyallahu 'anhuma, he explained the interpretation of the verse above:</p>\n<p>When Allah took Isa to heaven, he met his disciples, and compiled it in the house there were 12 hawariyin men, then Jesus said, \"Who connects you is replaced like my face, then he will be helped by me, and he will get a paradise of the same degree with me. </p>\n<p>Then stand the youngest, \"Me.\"</p>\n<p>\"Sit.\" Isa said.</p>\n<p>Prophet Jesus repeated his offer, and the young man raised his hand and declared \"I.\"</p>\n<p>Prophet Isa (Jesus) still told him to sit down. Up to 3 times. In the third, this young man raised his hand, \"Me.\" Then Jesus said, \"Fine, you are the person.\"</p>\n<p>Then he is likened to Isa (Jesus) and Isa (Jesus) is lifted through the vents on the roof, toward the sky.</p>\n<p>Then came the Jews who searched for him, they immediately imitated a similar human, and immediately killed him, then crucified him. (Source: Tafsir Ibn Kathir, 2/449).</p>\n<p>Meanwhile, Ibnu Katsir that was likened to Prophet Isa, was everyone who was his disciple. When the Jews surrounded the house, they denied and said: </p>\n<p>\"You have bewitch us. Show where Isa is, or we get you all out.\"</p>\n<p>Then one of them advanced, remembering promising Jesus that he would get heaven with Isa. Then the Jew killed the man and crucified him.</p>\n<p>Besides that, some Christians think that Judas - who betrayed the Jewish position of Jesus. He was the one who was likened to Jesus, then he was crucified. He said, \"I am not the person you are looking for, on the contrary I am showing you the person you are looking for.\" (Source: Tafsir Ibnu Katsir, 2/452)</p>\n<p>Based on these arguments and references, I can draw the conclusion that those who died on the cross were not the prophet Isa (Jesus), but the person who was likened to him.</p>\n<p><br></p>\n<p><br></p>","appDepth":2,"appParentPermlink":"pkj7bfsyq","appParentAuthor":"reborn99","musingAppId":"aU2p3C3a8N","musingAppVersion":"1.1","musingPostType":"answer"}" |
|---|
hiveblocks