**The Tholian Web (S03E09)**
Airdate: November 15th 1968
Written by: Judy Burns & Chet Richards
Directed by: Herb Wallerstein
Running Time: 50 minutes
One of the most reliable indicators of a high-quality episode of *Star Trek: The Original Series* (TOS) is its enduring influence on the broader *Star Trek* universe. Episodes that became cultural touchstones, inspired sequels, or were referenced in subsequent films and television series often achieved this status precisely because they resonated deeply with both contemporary audiences and hardcore fans. Such episodes transcended their initial broadcast to become embedded in the franchise’s lore, their themes, characters, or innovations deemed worthy of revisitation. This criterion is particularly illuminating when applied to Season 3 of TOS, a season often maligned for its uneven quality, budget constraints, and narrative missteps. Amidst this uneven terrain, *The Tholian Web* stands out as a very good piece of science fiction storytelling, a episode that not only overcame its production challenges but also left an indelible mark on *Star Trek*’s legacy.
The episode opens with the USS *Enterprise* investigating the disappearance of the Federation starship USS *Defiant*, last seen in uncharted space three weeks prior. Upon arrival, the crew discovers the *Defiant* adrift, its crew dead in a macabre tableau of mutual violence. When Captain Kirk, Spock, Dr. McCoy, and Chekov beam aboard, they encounter a harrowing mystery: the ship appears to flicker in and out of existence, a phenomenon Spock later identifies as a “spatial interphase” causing the vessel to oscillate between universes. As the away team attempts to retreat, the *Enterprise*’s transporter malfunctions due to interphase interference, allowing only three to return. Kirk, ever the self-sacrificing leader, remains aboard the *Defiant*, entrusting Spock with command and the imperative to rescue him. Meanwhile, the *Enterprise* crew begins succumbing to the same madness that doomed the *Defiant*, their sanity eroded by the interphase’s psychological toll. Compounding the crisis, the Tholian Assembly—a reclusive, insectoid alien species—arrives, demanding the *Enterprise* vacate their territory within hours. Spock, now in temporary command, refuses, prioritising Kirk’s survival over diplomatic compliance. The Tholians retaliate by constructing an “energy web,” a shimmering lattice of forcefields designed to trap the *Enterprise* in a temporal prison.
At the heart of *The Tholian Web*’s brilliance lies its script, a work of remarkable ambition and cohesion. Written by Judy Burns and Chet Richards as an unsolicited submission, the script deftly weaves three distinct narrative threads—the existential threat of the interphase, the psychological unraveling of the crew, and the geopolitical standoff with the Tholians—into a tightly paced, emotionally resonant hour of television. What elevates the script further is its bold decision to sideline Captain Kirk for much of the episode, a rare narrative choice that allows the supporting cast to shine. Leonard Nimoy’s Spock, typically restrained, reveals a haunting vulnerability as he grapples with the possibility of Kirk’s permanent loss. His interactions with DeForest Kelley’s McCoy are particularly striking, oscillating between bickering and mutual reliance in a dynamic that underscores the depth of their triad with Kirk. Meanwhile, Nichelle Nichols’ Uhura is given an unusually intimate moment in her quarters, clad in civilian attire, where she confronts her fear of succumbing to madness—a scene that humanises her beyond her usual role as the ship’s communications officer.
The script’s origins as a proposed foray into the fantasy genre add another layer of intrigue. Burns and Richards initially envisioned the *Defiant* haunted by spectral entities, a concept that Gene Roddenberry rejected as incompatible with *Star Trek*’s commitment to science fiction. The compromise—a ghost-like apparition of Kirk flickering between universes—retains the eerie tone while grounding the phenomenon in pseudo-scientific logic. This spectral imagery, though brief, enhances the episode’s tension, blending the uncanny with the rational in a way that epitomizes *Star Trek*’s unique narrative voice.
Visually, the episode is defined by the Tholians, whose angular, geometric ships and lattice-like energy web remain among TOS’s most iconic images. While the Tholians’ on-screen appearance has not aged well, their ships’ methodical weaving of the web is a triumph of practical effects. The use of chromatic lighting and model work to depict the web’s construction imbues the sequence with a sense of dread, amplifying the stakes as the *Enterprise*’s crew races against time.
The episode’s production history is as tumultuous as its narrative. Ralph Senensky, a veteran director of the series, was abruptly fired mid-shoot due to budgetary and scheduling conflicts, with Herb Wallerstein stepping in to complete the episode. Despite this upheaval, the pacing remains brisk yet deliberate, balancing action with necessary exposition. The directors also experiment with form: distorted fisheye lens sequences convey the crew’s descent into madness, a stylistic risk that pays off in visceral, disorienting visuals. These flourishes, achieved on a shoestring budget, speak to the ingenuity of the production team.
Perhaps the episode’s most enduring legacy lies in Kirk’s video message, a poignant farewell recorded for Spock and McCoy should he perish. Delivered with gravitas by William Shatner, the message not only crystallises the unspoken loyalty between the trio but also marks one of the earliest uses of a “video will” in television—a narrative device now commonplace in science fiction and beyond.
Decades later, *The Tholian Web*’s influence persists. The USS *Defiant* reemerges in *Star Trek: Deep Space Nine*, its name becoming synonymous with resilience in the Dominion War. More directly, *Enterprise*’s two-part episode *In the Mirror, Darkly* (2005) serves as a canonical sequel, exploring the *Defiant*’s cross-dimensional fate in the brutal Terran Empire of the Mirror Universe.
*The Tholian Web* is a testament to what made TOS revolutionary: a willingness to tackle complex themes—existential dread, loyalty under pressure, and the fragility of reality—within the framework of episodic science fiction. Its success lies not merely in its plot mechanics but in its emotional depth, technical ingenuity, and narrative ambition. For these reasons, it remains a cornerstone of the *Star Trek* canon, a episode that proves even in Season 3, the series could still reach for—and achieve—the stars.
RATING: 8/10 (+++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Leodex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9
Posted Using [INLEO](https://inleo.io/@drax/television-review-the-tholian-web-star-trek-s3x09-1967-5zp)
hiveblocks